The ultimate writer's guide to the Secret Identity trope

What is the Secret Identity trope?

The Secret Identity trope involves a character who lives a double life, concealing their true identity, often to protect themselves or others, or to carry out specific missions or tasks. This hidden identity can range from superheroes disguising themselves as ordinary citizens to spies, vigilantes, or even characters hiding their past or lineage.

Characteristics of the Secret Identity trope

At its core, the Secret Identity trope explores themes of privacy, the nature of self, duality, and the consequences of leading a double life. It highlights the psychological and emotional impact of maintaining a façade, the tension between an individual's public persona and private self, and the complexities of navigating relationships under the burden of secrecy. This trope is prevalent because it resonates with the universal human experience of concealing aspects of ourselves in different contexts, dramatizing the conflict between authenticity and necessity, and the desire for genuine connection versus the need for protection or duty.

Where did the Secret Identity trope come from?

Historically, the trope has roots in ancient mythology and folklore, where gods and heroes often assumed mortal guises to interact with humans. In literature, it became prominent in adventure and detective fiction of the 19th century, exemplified by characters like Zorro and later popularized in the 20th century through comic book superheroes. The evolution of the trope reflects changing societal attitudes toward identity, privacy, and the role of the individual in society, adapting to incorporate contemporary issues and technologies.

Genres & the Secret Identity trope

• Superhero Fiction: Central to the genre, where heroes conceal their powers to protect loved ones or maintain normalcy.
• Mystery and Thriller: Features characters with hidden pasts or double lives to build suspense and intrigue.
• Fantasy and Science Fiction: Often includes characters with secret magical abilities or hidden origins.
• Romance: Can involve characters hiding their true selves for various reasons, adding complexity to relationships.

Cross-genre Usage: The trope also appears in historical fiction, drama, and even comedy, where the revelation of secret identities can lead to profound transformations, conflicts, or humorous situations.

Examples of the Secret Identity trope

• "The Night Circus" by Erin Morgenstern: Characters with magical abilities lead double lives, hiding their true nature from the public and each other.
• "Cinder" by Marissa Meyer: A futuristic retelling of Cinderella, where the protagonist hides her identity as a cyborg and her lunar heritage.
• "The Scarlet Pimpernel" by Baroness Orczy: One of the earliest examples, featuring a nobleman leading a double life to save aristocrats during the French Revolution.
• "The Count of Monte Cristo" by Alexandre Dumas: The protagonist assumes multiple identities to seek vengeance and justice, showcasing the trope's flexibility and depth.

How to use the Secret Identity trope in creative ways

• Avoiding Clichés: Develop unique motivations and consequences for the secret identity beyond the traditional superhero narrative, exploring the psychological and emotional depth.
• Innovative Twists: Subvert expectations by having the character's secret identity revealed early on, focusing on the aftermath and the character's adaptation to a new reality.
• Character and Plot Integration: Ensure that the secret identity is integral to the character's development and the plot's progression, using it to explore themes of identity, trust, and transformation.
• Examples of Creative Use: A character whose secret identity is known to the audience but hidden from other characters, creating dramatic irony and tension. Or, explore a world where everyone must maintain a secret identity, examining the societal implications and personal costs.

‍